Stepping into Port Jervis Pizza, I wasn’t just greeted by the comforting aroma of baked cheese and garlic—but by a menu that reads like a love letter to classic Italian-American fare. Let’s talk flavor.
The pizza selection alone is a playground for cheese lovers. The classic Cheese Pizza is rich and golden, but it’s the Specialty Pizzas that steal the spotlight—especially the Garbage Cheese Pizza, a chaotic, cheesy masterpiece that somehow makes sense with every bite. The White Pizza series offers a lighter touch: creamy mozzarella meets tender spinach or crisp broccoli, and the Vegetable Pizza feels like the guilt-free excuse we all needed to devour more slices.
Appetizers set the stage with crispy Buffalo Wings that bring just the right amount of heat, and Mozzarella Sticks that stretch like a dream. Garlic Bread (with or without cheese) and golden Onion Rings are crunchy companions you don’t want to skip.
Soup lovers will find comfort in bowls of Tortellini, hearty Chicken Noodle, and rustic Pasta Fagioli—each one warm, wholesome, and clearly homemade.
The Calzones are pillowy, cheese-stuffed wonders—whether you go for the classic or twist it up with broccoli, spinach, or pepperoni. Heroes? Both hot and cold versions pack serious punch, from the meaty Italian Combo Hero to the ooey-gooey Chicken Parmigiana Hero.
Burgers and deluxe options are served American-style, with the Pizza Burger Deluxe earning extra points for creativity. Traditional Italian dinners like Veal, Chicken, or Eggplant Parmigiana come generously portioned, with Spaghetti & Meatballs as a nostalgic staple.
Even the kids have their own flavorful lineup—from Baked Ziti to Chicken Nuggets & Fries. Finish strong with sweet treats like Oreo Pie, Cannoli, or Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Pie.